Why Liverpool are internally unsure about hiring Xabi Alonso despite Arne Slot struggles

Reports indicate that Liverpool harbor internal uncertainties regarding the potential appointment of former Bayer Leverkusen manager Xabi Alonso to succeed Arne Slot.

Alonso, a former player for Liverpool, has demonstrated considerable promise in his relatively short managerial career, notably by guiding Bayer Leverkusen to a Bundesliga title.

However, according to The Times, Alonso's preference for a three-at-the-back formation could be a significant deterrent, echoing concerns raised when Ruben Amorim was previously considered for the managerial role at Anfield.

While Alonso achieved significant success with his wing-back system at Leverkusen, it is a tactical approach that historically has not enjoyed widespread, consistent success in English football.

Furthermore, adopting such a system would necessitate a substantial period of adaptation for Liverpool, a club that has largely adhered to a consistent playing style for many years and built its squad accordingly.

Despite these considerations, Alonso's impressive track record suggests that his appointment could be a compelling option to replace Slot, especially given the dramatic downturn in team performance experienced this season.

Arne Slot's Liverpool Premier League Record

Slot LFC PL record	Games	Wins	Draws	Losses	Win %
2024/25	38	25	9	4	65.79%
2025/26	31	14	7	10	45.16%

It remains to be seen if Slot can turn the season around and secure his position, especially considering the promising nature of his initial campaign, which has been followed by current struggles.

While Alonso might be a popular choice among fans, it is evident that Liverpool's hierarchy maintains a more reserved stance, an approach that can be commendable as it reflects their commitment to a clearly defined long-term strategy.

This commitment, though it may lead to occasional downturns, is generally intended to ensure Liverpool's sustained stability and success, rather than merely chasing immediate, fleeting solutions.